I was going to be writing on another subject for Part three - but I decided to change it after reading some comments on different forums over the weekend and thinking - Why are some traders missing the obvious ?

Here's a few questions to ask yourself -

1. Can you drive a car and do you hold a full driving licence ? If so - was you a good driver after your first week or first 50 miles ? Was you more experienced after say 5 years and 50k+ miles under your belt? Was you a better driver after drivings say 5 different cars in different parts of the country or even abroad ??

2. Have you ever decided to accomplish a new skill - ie skiing or snowboarding - go karting - sailing - ten pin bowling etc ? Have you noticed you started to improve after time ? It might be after a few months or in the case of some skills - it can take many months and years??

3. When you have learnt a new skill or sport etc - have you generally found there is a proper way to do it and other people really don't try and mislead you and send you down the wrong way ? ie if skiing - no teacher would say on your first day - go to the top of the highest mountain - find a "black run" that's really steep and just go for it ??

4. Have you noticed you can grade many of the activities that involve some type of skills - ie at the start you are a beginner - and then after a few weeks or months you become intermediate or semi skilled and then may be a few years down the road you become experienced or advanced or even over time you can become an expert on the particular skill - ie part of a small percentage who are at the top of their skill level  etc

OK - hopefully you agree with what I have been mentioning above and so now lets relate it to FX Trading

The main first reason most traders fail is because they never get past beginner level 

Beginner level can range from just 3 months to even 3 year plus. I will give you an example - I have read of one trader who was made redundant from his job and decided that for 4 months he would focus full time on trying to learn how to trade profitable . He was lucky - he had a mentor ( not me ) who he had known for a few years as a friend. He spent over 4 months an average of 50 hrs a week studying and learning and watching charts and taking initially demo trades. He was guided by his mentor - so was told what to focus on

At the end of 4 months - he had under his belt over 800 hrs of concentrated FX learning  - not much but the same as many traders who spend just a few hours a week of 2 years part time . He found out he was still really a beginner and was not consistently profitable - even after all the help he had from his mentor. In fact he realised 800 hrs was just not enough - he had not learnt enough.

Now that sums it up - many new retail traders give it less than 100 hrs of study - and then either blow their account and give up - or become hooked and realise they need to learn so much more.

Personally I think you need a few thousand hours of study and chart watching to even get to an intermediate level. It does not matter if you read 5 books on FX Trading - or even 30 books - books alone will not get you there - that's like trying to learn how to drive a car without getting behind the wheel on the road.

Now thinking about it - if you spend say 15 hrs a week - ie like say 3 mornings / afternoons / evenings and then studying articles and books at the weekend - then in a year - that's less then 750 hrs - so even 3 years is not even 3000 hrs . 

If you were employed by a Bank or hedge fund etc and then taught their method - in just 6 months you would have clocked up over 1500 hrs and you would either be at a good level -or told to look elsewhere  etc.

I am amazed why some traders who I would say have a good "brain" cannot understand why a trader with over 25k of live trades behind him is at a better more advanced skill level than another trader with only 1500 trades ??

OK some traders at say 3 or 4000 live trades will be far better than other traders who might have taken 8 or 10,000 live trades - that all depends on their method and their understanding of the whole "subject" and their personality - ie discipline, memory, health , age etc etc. 

The majority of retail traders on any FX forum  ( other than this one ) will comprise of the majority who have less than a few years experience. Many will want to pretend they have say 4 years - when really its not quite 2 years. You will only find a small percentage of FX traders who are full time - ie trading every day and week and generally spending over 25+ hrs a week at their activity . Even the part time traders who have 5 or 7 years plus of FX trading behind them are still only at "intermediate level " they maybe making a profit or break-even - but will still have losing months and are not as consistent as they would like

You are only going to find the real consistent traders - ie never have losing weeks and have at least 3 years of proper results in all conditions etc as a very very small percentage  - I don't think they exist on copy trader sites simply because most full time proper traders would be making enough money without bothering to supplement it.

I will be interested to hear from any Forexmospherians who maybe want to expand on this subject  - we need to make sure "newbie" FX traders realise - there is do much dross and misinformation - due to lack of retail trading knowledge out it all these other forums 

Good Trading


Forex Trader,
Previous Contributor: FXstreet, T2W, Forexmosgate, Forexmospherians.com
Currencies: Various: Intraday, Scalp,
Senior Technical Market Analysis


  • Well said...I am full time now..learning & practising...:)

  • I would only say that it is far easier to find good driving lessons than fx guidance since so much misinformation is on the net, also you need to count in fake gurus, fake EA-s that will take your money and spin you around so it really takes persistence to learn.

  • So True Viktor

    When you learn to drive - or play golf or take up jogging etc - normally you are not going to receive a loads of false information - Ok driving instructors might want you to take say 20 lessons - when back in my days many learner drivers passed their test first or second time with less than 10 or 12 lessons - but then again - driving in traffic today is different than 30 -40 yrs ago

    You can have dodgy spreadbetting brokers wanting to mislead you - because they can make more money from you - and you can have also some commercial and professional traders wanting you to keep on failing - it's in their interest to see a 80+% failure rate rather than just 50% . It took me a few months in my early trading journey to realise its best to not just believe all you hear and read - try it and test it yourself 

  • YEs Sfx but you are still immersed in a toxic environment elsewhere. Why is this?

    • Hi MM,

      I am still over there because of our mentor's request. :) To show something.


This reply was deleted.

You need to be a member of Forexmospherians - Forex Traders Social Network to add comments!

Join Forexmospherians - Forex Traders Social Network

Helpful Hints

Share a Trading Tip, Trick, Knowledge or Technique with the Community. Try to avoid just simply posting a link or video and saying this is great. Explain what makes it great or how this was useful. Sometimes things are simply entertaining but still useful and so explain in detail with diagrams, photos or charts. Descriptions with as many details are always interesting to read and so say what could be useful to know here. Community members are welcome to comment, ask questions or add to a post.

"Keep a Record of the Business or Currency Pair Traded. Reasons why the Trade was taken. When was the Exit. How and why the Trade turned out the way it did"

"It's my pleasure to be part of this forum, which is always different than other places & with a friendly environment. Glad to be in this team"

"Yes, the truth requires neither our belief nor understanding. However to harness truth and apply it for our benefit we must at a minimum allow that it is possible".

"We all know we will never be 100% Accurate with 100% win rate over 100's or 1000's of trades - but as long as your winning pips and money - add up to a lot more than your losing pips and money - then "Bingo" you are successful winning FX trader"

"I figured this was a legitimate break, so I went on the hunt for evidence, so here in succession is the list of clues I used to make my decision:

Rejection of market and weekly pivot at ema confluence.

Complete and broken head and shoulders on 1hr time frame.

Broadening formation on daily with test and rejection of 200 day ma

Bull hinge on daily and Renko stochastic.

Positive momentum on 5min, 1hr, 4hr and daily chart"

"Remember that all models are wrong; the practical question is how wrong do they have to be to not be useful" - George E. P. Box

"Sometimes You Win,

Sometimes you Learn".

"Forex Market analysis relies on two types of analysis much like Stock Markets:

Technical Forex Market Analysis views the data on a chart and considers that the News and Data is built into the Price already (economic, political, social, sentimental and psychological). Various tools and indicators will be used by technical traders, for instance MACD, Bollinger Bands, Moving Averages and more.

Fundamental Forex Market Analysis also uses indicators, for instance reports, Gross Domestic Production (GDP), Retail sales, Consumer spending, Industrial Production, Consumer Price Index, Commodities, Economic Calendars, Balance of Trade levels which could identify Trends between other Nations and more."

"Short rapid bursts and quick glimpses of an entry, trigger activated, trail in place and exit strategy and plan already set. Within a blink of an eye, instinctively the buy/sell button is pushed. The hammer falls and clanks decisively, echoing, sparking, like steel upon steel and the trade is executed. A Traders heart beats on with perfect set up, closely aligned with strict parameters, ready to continue the attack or recoil on a wire. Wrap the profit and then stand down, ready for the next hunt"

"When we are talking about sentiment it is very hard to say that this sentiment will prevail another 6, 9, 13 hours. Sentiment is not a constant line. Main trend is bearish, tech picture on daily is bearish, even intraday neutral. Nobody restrict to play long eur short usd position with the target at 1.12 or even 1.1361, this is every traders individual choice as always"

Latest Activity

Alex updated their profile
Aug 17
Paul commented on FXCoalface's blog post You Can lead a Human to Forex Knowledge .........
Nov 25, 2022
IFC Markets, Oluwatayo Oluwawunmi, Jake and 1 more joined Forexmospherians - Forex Traders Social Network
Nov 21, 2022
Roland Trevelyan-Cresswell liked Sir Gissachance's blog post Insider trading and insider information?
Nov 15, 2022
Alfred, Christina Florand and Roland Trevelyan-Cresswell joined Forexmospherians - Forex Traders Social Network
Nov 11, 2022
Sir Gissachance commented on Sir Gissachance's blog post A New Forex Trader | "I'm Like a Dog Chasing Cars"
May 20, 2021
Stella Abu updated their profile
May 18, 2021
Rishi Raj Singh and Silva joined Forexmospherians - Forex Traders Social Network
May 17, 2021
longle4395 commented on david william's blog post EUR / USD can rise more
Dec 21, 2020
longle4395 commented on Daniel Stasziek's blog post Daniel's FX Trading
Dec 18, 2020
Sir Gissachance commented on Sir Gissachance's blog post A New Forex Trader | "I'm Like a Dog Chasing Cars"
Dec 18, 2020
longle4395 commented on Sir Gissachance's blog post A New Forex Trader | "I'm Like a Dog Chasing Cars"
Dec 17, 2020